On the Israel belongs to the Jews thread, BGurd attributes to Yusuf Ali some statements that are not in his commentary. Could you check your versions of YA's commentary?
Apart from the fact that I have already mentioned YA's limitations, he was nonetheless a person of ethics, and did not make statements about the Prophet putting in pagan rituals into Islam. That is a evangelical lie put into the man's words. But do me a favor and confirm please by checking, not be "feeling." I used my ALIM cd.
Now it looks like we got anotehr type of crusader here..those who lie. Is one thing to be stupid, is another to blatantly lie.

quote:

Originally posted by dara shikoh:
On the Israel belongs to the Jews thread, BGurd attributes to Yusuf Ali some statements that are not in his commentary. Could you check your versions of YA's commentary?
Apart from the fact that I have already mentioned YA's limitations, he was nonetheless a person of ethics, and did not make statements about the Prophet putting in pagan rituals into Islam. That is a evangelical lie put into the man's words. But do me a favor and confirm please by checking, not be "feeling." I used my ALIM cd.
Now it looks like we got anotehr type of crusader here..those who lie. Is one thing to be stupid, is another to blatantly lie.

BGurd is hindu, Crusaders are Christians.

quote:

Originally posted by Sunil:

quote:

Originally posted by dara shikoh:
On the Israel belongs to the Jews thread, BGurd attributes to Yusuf Ali some statements that are not in his commentary. Could you check your versions of YA's commentary?
Apart from the fact that I have already mentioned YA's limitations, he was nonetheless a person of ethics, and did not make statements about the Prophet putting in pagan rituals into Islam. That is a evangelical lie put into the man's words. But do me a favor and confirm please by checking, not be "feeling." I used my ALIM cd.
Now it looks like we got anotehr type of crusader here..those who lie. Is one thing to be stupid, is another to blatantly lie.

BGurd is hindu, Crusaders are Christians.

If he is...then he is a real evil person. Why so? He just tried to poke fun at hindus..if it is done so that I can defend hinduiam and he can gleefully claim "I am a hindu" then it shows his lack of ethics.
I really don't care who he is anyway..but from the texts, it would seem that he has assumed the mantle of a wannabe crusader, and for them, I have a special scorn. Especially when it comes to the Palestianians..who were screwed by the byzantine christians, and who, in many cases, still remained christian....and when these wannabes come on GNI, with their hatred for Islam, trying to lump all Pals into the category of Muslims,,then it gets my goat.
If BGurd is a hindu...nah..lemme save that for later. I am not going into overkill mode yet.